The bewildering world of road bottom brackets can drive anyone to despair (including mechanics), but once you’ve narrowed down exactly which type fits your bike, there’s still plenty of options to choose from. Is the huge price hike of ceramic units worth the extra investment or is it just hype? Or should you look into something a little more heavy-duty?
The best road bottom brackets are not always the most expensive. For some, a cheaper option that you replace more often may not be the worse choice, especially if you have the tools and knowledge to replace it yourself. However the performance of these units often tails off quickly in bad conditions and therefore higher quality and more heavy duty stainless bearings can be a great solution, especially if you run one bike all year round - such as anendurance bikeorcommuter bike.
如果你足够幸运有一个专用的666beplay/ race bike, you may then want to consider ceramic bearings. These have all the benefits of stainless but with even less friction, helping you save valuable watts. If properly cared for, ceramic bearings can also outlast steel and will suffer less from corrosion.
The best equipment used in the correct way will always improve the performance of your bike and therefore your enjoyment of your riding. This isn’t just relevant to the pros shaving off a tenth of a second in a TT. In fact you could argue the opposite, that it's more important for a normal rider who is looking to maximize their ride. If good quality equipment makes your bike fun to ride, you’re likely to ride it more often and for longer! Here’s a selection of the best road bottom bracket upgrades we've tried and our experience of them.
Best Road Bottom Brackets
A name which is synonymous with high quality bearings and most people’s first thought when discussing upgrades. Ceramicspeed make a unit to fit almost any frame/crank combo. The standard Un-coated version of the BB features ceramic bearings which can be filled with your choice of grease, to suit the riding you’ll be doing.
Long-life grease extends the service period of the BB and is best for mixed weather and gravel, whilst the Performance grease is great for TT bikes and Summer road bikes – if you have your bike serviced regularly it’s possible to swap grease depending on the season.
Ceramicspeed does make a point of saying that a ceramic BB doesn’t mean you can neglect the servicing like many people assume – the units still need the same care and attention that steel bearings require, but it is true that ceramic units will wear less than steel units when cared for properly.
我的测试Ceramicspeed单元实际上是一个标准的version that I bought several years ago now and is just about due to outlast the bike it’s been in, and it’s four year warranty (Ceramicspeed also offer a coated version with a lifetime warranty). Most of the time I’ve run performance grease in the unit and I’ve done a very simple service of it twice a year. It’s still noticeably easier to spin than my other bikes and I’ve experienced zero creaks/noise. It’s true that this has been my summer road bike for the last three years but I’ve ridden in all weathers and the BB has never skipped a beat. It's been a joy to ride, making me feel slightly better about the initial cost of fitting.
Similarly to Ceramicspeed, C-Bear produce a BB for just about any combination of frame/groupset and the chart on the website is very easy to use to help you pick the right unit. You simply identify what BB shell your frame is and what spindle/crankset you have and C-Bear will tell you which BB fits in between the two. I fitted a threaded unit to one of my bikes six months ago and have fitted many customer units in the last three years. I’ve been really impressed by the aftercare both from Belgium and from the UK importer.
When I started writing this review I realised that after six months I haven’t actually needed or even thought about servicing the BB. I wouldn’t claim it’s a fit-and-forget unit as it will need servicing just like a steel BB at some point, but given that we’ve had a relatively mild spring in the UK I’ve not needed to worry. The BB still feels silky smooth and silent - like I mentioned in the introduction, this is a big factor in making me want to ride my bike.
One of the reasons that the C-Bear unit is so quiet is that they’ve completely done away with all loose parts such as wave washers, spacers and adapters. This is absolutely critical in the reduction of noise and can only be achieved when a brand like this makes a BB option specific to each frame/crank option. It’s a huge amount of work on their part and more than justifies the price tag in my opinion.
The price itself is one of the selling features of C-Bear – depending on the option you go for the C-Bear units can be half the price of Ceramicspeed. It's certainly a significant difference and quite probably a major consideration to many riders looking to upgrade. It puts C-Bear in the realms of some of the more expensive OE brands and packs an impressive punch.
Chris King design and make their own bearings in-house and that’s been at the heart of everything the company has done to earn its stripes over the years. My own CK unit has been fitted to various bikes over the last few years including a spell on a ‘cross bike so it’s had a proper testing! The bearings are completely serviceable and CK have some great videos about how they make bearings and how to service them.
On various bikes I’ve use lots of different greases in the BB, from long-life in the cross bike through to even just oil for a short period in a TT bike. In most cases a mid-friction high performance grease works best and is what I’ve used 90% of the time. Initially Chris King intends there to be very little drag, but due to the way the Angular Contact Bearing works this actually lessens over time – they claim “they get better with age”.
This may raise eyebrows but my unit certainly seems to have rolled with the punches over the years and it’s still behaving. I have experienced a little noise from time to time but I caught this early in each instance and following a full strip and rebuild (including removing and refitting the threaded unit) its always returned to life without an issue. Therefore I’d definitely recommend regular maintenance when using these BBs.
Price wise the CK stainless units sit somewhere in between the Ceramicspeed and C-Bear options, offering a good alternative to both. They also come in a multitude of colours to suit your build.
A relative newcomer to the market, Kogel quickly received a reputation for high quality kit at a fairly affordable price. Branding is clean, all the BBs are finished in satin anodizing and the product is highly functional rather than being offered in lots of garish colours – it’s very much there to do the job.
As with my Chris King unit , my Kogel BB has been on a few different bikes over the years and has been serviced accordingly. I have noticed that the Kogel unit requires a tiny bit more attention than the other I’ve tested but still well within the bounds of a regular service. Interestingly Kogel can supply optional “road” seals or standard “cross” seals to the same bearing in most instances.
Cross seals have slightly more drag but will give you better waterproofing and in most cases are the way to go. Road seals would be great in a race bike or a summer bike and these are the ones that are featured in those videos of the high speed spinning cranks that most people visualize when thinking about ceramic BBs. I like the fact that these are interchangeable because in theory you could make a seasonal change when you service your bike.
The BB has a 2 year warranty which isn’t quite as good as the other options but it’s still double (in most cases) that of many of the standard/OE brands. Similarly priced to the Chris King units I think Kogel is a serious contender and the choice might just come down to what suits the bike best.
希望是建立在英国和做一些of the best products for our climate and riding since they started in their humble Yorkshire workshop. Whilst not primarily thought of as a road brand, Hope make a full list of suitable products including its excellent BB options.
One of the massive advantages to the Hope unit is the incredibly low price – when you compare it to many of the other options out there, it stacks up very competitively, especially when you consider that you could replace it several times during the lifespan of the more expensive products.
But, will you therefore need to be constantly swapping BBs out? Simply, no! They last very well indeed, probably due to the fact that these products were first and foremost tested on mountain bikes and were always designed to take abuse from both the weather and the terrain.
The BBs won’t spin as friction free as some of the others on this test but, as stated, that’s not the point – they’re just very well made units that are designed to get the job done. A little grease as part of a normal service is enough to keep them running smoothly and when they finally give up they’re much cheaper to replace. Maybe not the choice for your TT or race bike but very much definitely worth considering for your all-rounder or your gravel bike.
Similarly to the Hope units, these BBs are designed to get the job done in tough conditions. Along with Hope these are my go-to units for general replacement and Wheels Manufacturing have a massive range of BBs to suit pretty much any combination.
The ACB stands for Angular Contact Bearing and is similar to what many of the higher priced units use. This simply means that the bearing is designed to work under load from multiple directions, unlike a standard sealed bearing which only supports load in one axis. This is quite important as many of the cheaper options just use standard bearings.
阳极氧化膜的单位有选择红色或black in most cases and look really neat on most bikes. They don’t offer the reduced friction benefits of some of the ceramic options but again that’s not the point – the big benefit is the weatherproofing and the quality, which is similar to Hope. In most cases they use Enduro bearings which are recognized as the industries upgrade standard. They are superior in my view to the majority of the standard/OE options.
One of the big positives are the screw-together units that Wheels Manufacturing produce – if you’re getting the dreaded BB creak from a Pressfit BB that’s been fitted badly at some point, the Screw-together style unit can normally solve this – again it does need to be fitted correctly but it can easily resurrect life into an old steed. Like the Hope units I’d recommend these to anyone wanting a good solid performing BB that doesn’t break the bank.
Best Road Bottoms Brackets
What are the main types of bottom bracket?
It's worth thinking about this as a two part question: what frame is the BB going in? And, what axle will you be using? The BB is essentially just the bit in between these two things. Some options simply aren't possible due to the size constraints on bearings, but the vast majority are and systems like SRAM's DUB aim to solve the issue of compatibility forever by offering a BB for almost every standard.
Common frame standards are BSA Threaded, Pressfit (41mm), Pressfit 30 (46mm), BB386, T47 and BB30. Some manufacturers like Trek, Cannondale and Cervelo have BB standards that are unique to the brand but some aftermarket brands will still cater for these.
Common axle standards are 24mm, 30mm (for BB30), 30mm (for PF30/386), DUB, GXP and Ultra-torque. Shimano settled on 24mm when they came up with Hollowtech 2 and have used it ever since. Around the same time Campagnolo settled upon it's hirth jointed Ultra-Torque system which it still uses in most instances. SRAM offered three options (BB30/PF30/GXP) for a long time and recently has now settled on DUB as their standard. There are still a few SRAM GXP options available where the driveside axle is 24mm and the non-driveside is 22mm!
How long should a bottom bracket last?
As with many components on a bike this depends on three things - maintenance, conditions and usage. For instance at a cyclocross race, the riders are racing in the sand and having their bikes cleaned with a jetwash, but what you don't see on TV is that it then takes a full day of work to strip and rebuild each bike ready for the next race - bikes are typically treated to a full service 30 times a season! On your home roads, the conditions you'll be riding in are far less severe but the key to making anything last is some regular TLC.
The tricky thing with a BB is you'll need special tools to get to it. This is why, even on a summer bike we would thoroughly recommend using a medium or heavy weight high performance grease for the job, which any good mechanic should be able to fit in the bearings. In winter it's worth using long life grease to help keep the wet and the grime at bay. Even if you have the tools and knowledge to do this you're unlikely to do it very often so always go for a quality grease that's up to the job!
When should I replace my bottom bracket?
With many of the options here, if they are properly serviced, it should take a very long time for them to wear out. In general the BB will start to develop a low grumbly noise, especially during high torque pedaling - this may develop into a creak and finally into play.
Some of the options here, like the Hope and Wheels MFG BBs, feature a set of alloy cups which the bearings are pressed into and it's sometimes possible to replace the bearing rather than the whole unit.
In general, at the first sign of trouble, get the bearings serviced as this may help avoid the cost of a complete replacement.
What tools are needed for replacing a bottom bracket?
Each manufacturer has specific tools, some of which happen to work for more than one brand. The major tool brands all offer various cup tools to suit the many options, but it's often worth checking if the brand of BB you're buying can sell you the appropriate tool at the same time - they're the experts so they're more likely to sell you the correct tool.
Pressfit BBs require a specific press to fit them and often a specific tool to remove them. Don't ever be tempted to bodge this job as it could easily write off your frameset. The tooling can be expensive so I'd recommend getting your local bike shop or your local mechanic to fit this for you.
你可以学着做在家里,在大多数实例s, is crank removal and basic re-greasing of the bearings. As mentioned above, this isn't a job you'll want to do all the time, but if you can regrease the bearing as soon as you hear any unwanted noise you could save yourself a lot of money in the long run. This also allows you to change the grease you use depending on the season and usage. In many cases to do this job you'll simply need Allen keys, a pick tool and a torque wrench - you could ask you're local mechanic if they can run you through this as a 1-to-1 service the first time you attempt it, or have a look at the manufacturers YouTube page as many will have tutorials. It's very rewarding to service a BB yourself as you can really feel the difference when you do the job well and it'll should save you a lot of money over time.
-
-
Garmin’s health-tracking metrics explained - understand what your smartwatch is telling you
A professional cycling coach takes us through the most useful metrics for cyclists
-
Tom Pidcock aims to go ‘a step further’ at Tour de France 2023
Ineos' Rod Ellingworth says British rider ‘still has some work to do’ in order to make GC push main objective